At 9 p.m. this Saturday, November 21, Uncle Giuseppe's in Melville stops taking Thanksgiving catering orders. Mighty Fine on Green Street stops taking Thanksgiving preorders the same day. Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 26, so a Huntington household has two days from today to decide who is baking the pie and who is roasting the turkey. After Saturday, the week runs on pickup windows that the kitchens have already set. A week later, Huntington Village shifts its attention one block over to Wall Street.
Saturday, November 21: The Order Books Close
Mighty Fine is at 43 Green Street. It takes Thanksgiving preorders through 11/21 for pickup in Huntington from Monday, November 23, through Thanksgiving itself. Its order menu lists sweet pies from $21 to $34, including apple and a pumpkin-spice latte pie. The same menu has savory pot pies and other baked goods, so you can order the dessert table and a weeknight dinner for the busy days before the holiday together.
Uncle Giuseppe's at 890 Walt Whitman Road in Melville is the option for a large table. Its 2026 holiday catering page lists Thanksgiving packages for 8 to 10 people, 14 to 16, and up to 21. The Thanksgiving catering menu also sells turkey, sides, pasta and desserts à la carte, with a $100 minimum order. The 9 p.m. Saturday cutoff applies to everything on that menu, so you need your guest count before then.
Kerber's Farm runs its own Huntington Thanksgiving collection, and turkey orders there start with a deposit. A fresh, uncooked bird holds for $50 in any size from 10–14 pounds up to 25–30 pounds. You pay the rest at $7.95 a pound, and turkeys are picked up in Huntington only, on a day you choose at checkout. The sides on the Kerber's Thanksgiving page include:
- Traditional stuffing and smashed potatoes, $24 each
- A quart of homemade turkey gravy or fresh cranberry sauce, $22 each
- Roasted Brussels sprouts and honey maple carrots, $26 each
- Whipped sweet potatoes, from $25
- A 9-inch mac and cheese pie at $30, or $35 for the gluten-free version
If Kerber's is part of your plan, place that order this week along with the others.
The Purple Elephant works on a different system. Its Thanksgiving carryout is vegan and mostly gluten-free, with roasted turkey available as the one non-vegan option. You order by phone at 631-651-5002. Supplies are limited, and orders are filled first come, first served. Without a set deadline, the real cutoff is whenever the kitchen sells out, which makes this the one call that shouldn't wait until Saturday.
Monday Through Wednesday: The Pickup Windows
Once the order is in, the week depends on when you can get to each counter. Mighty Fine starts handing over preorders on Monday, November 23. That makes it the only kitchen here with pickup days spread across the whole week. Pies can come home early in the week, before the roads and parking lots fill.
Uncle Giuseppe's pickup runs from 8 a.m. to 7 p.m. on Wednesday, November 25, and from 7 a.m. to noon on Thanksgiving morning. The Purple Elephant has a shorter Wednesday window, from 3 to 5 p.m. Wednesday afternoon can stack up quickly. If one household orders vegan sides from The Purple Elephant and a turkey package from Uncle Giuseppe's, both pickups fall inside the same two-hour stretch. Plan the Wednesday route around the shorter Purple Elephant window.
Wednesday Night in the Village
Once the cooking is underway, Huntington Village has two scheduled late nights on Thanksgiving Eve. Finnegan's is holding a Thanksgiving Eve party that starts at 10 p.m., with a $10 cover. At 65 Wall Street, IVY is hosting a 21-and-over DJ night on Wednesday, November 25, from 10 p.m. to 3 a.m., with Rick Wonder, Fotsbeats and Billy Peterson on the lineup. Both start after the Wednesday pickup windows close, so the errands and the night out don't compete for the same hours.
Thursday, November 26: The Morning Counter and the Dining Room
Thanksgiving morning has its own short schedule. Mighty Fine is open from 8 a.m. to noon on November 26. Uncle Giuseppe's pickup also ends at noon, after opening at 7 a.m. The Purple Elephant's Thursday window runs from 10 a.m. to noon. By midday, the takeout kitchens on this list have handed off their last orders.
For households that would rather not host, three dining rooms are serving on the holiday, and each sets its table differently.
Restaurant Prime, at 117 North New York Avenue, serves its regular à la carte menu and holiday specials from 11:30 a.m. to 8 p.m. Its Thanksgiving buffet runs from 1 to 5 p.m. at $85++ per adult and $40++ per child ages 2 to 11, and children under 2 eat free. Reservations are strongly suggested. The restaurant's page also says it is not suitable for children under 6, so the child price fits a table with school-age kids.
Jonathan's, at 15 Wall Street, serves a three-course Thanksgiving dinner for $65 per person this year. Guests choose turkey or Virginia ham, with sides and dessert, and a holiday à la carte menu is also available, according to Mommy Poppins' 2026 roundup of Long Island restaurants open on Thanksgiving. At $65, Jonathan's three courses cost $20 less than Prime's adult buffet price before Prime's tax and tip are added.
In Centerport, Mill Pond Steak & Seafood is listed for Thanksgiving 2026 on its menus page. It is serving the full à la carte menu plus holiday specials, including a $49 turkey dinner plate. Its Thanksgiving reservation listing on OpenTable shows times on November 26 from 11 a.m. through 7:30 p.m., half an hour before Prime's 11:30 a.m. opening. If your family plans an early meal or a late one, Mill Pond's hours cover both.
Saturday, November 28: The Village Changes Over
Two days after Thanksgiving, the Town of Huntington holds its holiday parade. The Town's announcement says this year's parade marks the 250th anniversary of American independence. The parade starts at 5:30 p.m. at the Home Depot on New York Avenue. It runs along New York Avenue and Main Street and ends at Main Street and West Neck Road, according to Living Huntington's event listing.
The tree lighting begins at about 6:30 p.m., right after the parade. It is the official start of the Huntington Holiday Spectacular at 12 Wall Street. That address is a few doors from Jonathan's at 15 Wall Street. The block where some families eat Thanksgiving dinner on Thursday becomes the village's holiday gathering place on Saturday.
The Spectacular is free and needs no tickets. It is open every day from noon to 10 p.m. through January 3, 2027. Its light shows start every hour, on the hour, and last 30 minutes. They run from 5 to 9 p.m. Monday through Thursday, 5 to 10 p.m. on Fridays, noon to 10 p.m. on Saturdays and noon to 9 p.m. on Sundays. The Spectacular's email list is managed by the Huntington Village BID, which sends updates on showtimes and special events. Because the weekend shows start at noon, families with young children can catch one in daylight on the first Sunday, November 29, without staying out until the evening shows.
For more on the village's dining rooms, see our earlier look at Huntington Village's newest rooms. The Huntington neighborhood guide has the wider picture.
The Agency Long Island follows these village dates as closely as the market. If the holidays have you thinking about a larger table, or a home closer to Wall Street for next year's parade, we're glad to talk it through. Contact Us.