Long Beach is one of the most iconic shoreline destinations on the South Shore. Known for its lively boardwalk, white sand beaches, and easy access to New York City via the LIRR, Long Beach attracts both year-round residents and seasonal visitors. The town blends a relaxed surf-town vibe with walkable neighborhoods, diverse restaurants, and an active community life, making it ideal for those who want to be close to the action while still enjoying oceanfront tranquility.
Bayville, located on the North Shore along the Long Island Sound, offers a more quiet and quaint alternative to some of the larger beach communities. With picturesque views, private beaches, and charming streets, Bayville is perfect for families or retirees seeking a peaceful waterside escape. Its small-town feel is enhanced by local favorites like waterfront seafood restaurants and scenic spots like the Bayville Adventure Park and Ransom Beach.
Fire Island, while technically a barrier island, is a unique coastal gem that deserves a spot on any beach lover’s radar. With no cars allowed in many communities and only ferry access from the mainland, Fire Island offers a slower, more intentional way of life. Popular hamlets like Ocean Beach and Saltaire provide a true beach town feel, complete with boardwalk paths, charming beach cottages, and a strong sense of community.
Southold, nestled on the North Fork, offers a peaceful, elegant version of beach life surrounded by vineyards, farms, and the gentle waters of the Peconic Bay and Long Island Sound. The beaches here—like Cedar Beach and Town Beach—are known for their quiet, clean shoreline and spectacular sunsets. Southold is also part of Long Island’s wine country, home to some of the best vineyards and farm-to-table dining on the East Coast. With its historic charm, scenic beauty, and strong sense of community, Southold is perfect for those looking for a refined, nature-centered coastal lifestyle.
Sayville, nestled along the Great South Bay, offers a blend of coastal living and historical charm. Known for its walkable downtown, marina, and ferry access to Fire Island, Sayville provides the convenience of shore living without the heavy tourism. The town features beautiful Victorian homes, bayfront parks, and a tight-knit community atmosphere. Its blend of affordability, beauty, and location make it a hidden gem among Long Island’s waterfront towns.
Whether you’re looking for weekend escapes or year-round coastal living, these five towns each offer their own version of the beach life dream. From vibrant communities to serene hideaways, Long Island’s shoreline towns have something for every lifestyle. If you're considering a move closer to the coast, our team at The Agency is here to help you find the perfect beachside home.
